Has life review really been measured in the brain?

A few weeks ago, striking news appeared in several media outlets: “They capture for the first time what happens to the brain before dying: life could pass before our eyes.”

Fuente: (https://www.larazon.es/sociedad/20220228/2ggglw3tnzb5jf6ejoybvapfui.html).

The text read that a group of neuroscientists had for the first time casually captured the brain activity of a person immediately after death. Gamma waves associated with the retrieval of memories appeared in the EEG, leading to speculation that these waves could reflect the moment of the life review recounted in NDEs.

As always, it is advisable to go to the original texts, to the articles published in professional journals, and initially put in quotes what appears in the mass media, which always seek to maximize the audience and ensure that “reality does not spoil a good headline.”

A detailed reading of the original article (“Enhanced Interplay of Neuronal Coherence and Coupling in the Dying Human Brain”

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnagi.2022.813531/full ) already reveals that the authors themselves give six reasons why hasty conclusions should not be drawn from this case: in summary, it is a single case of an epileptic patient, with intracranial hemorrhage, and having received anticonvulsant medication, his brain rhythms were most likely altered. Therefore it is not a particularly paradigmatic case.

In any case, the most “bold” statement the authors make is this: “It is intriguing to speculate that this (electrical) activity could reflect a last “memory of life” that could occur in a state close to death.” We are therefore faced with an “intriguing speculation” according to the authors themselves.

Although the article speaks of a “clinical cardiorespiratory arrest” in the 720th second of monitoring, in the electrocardiogram graph itself, it is observed that after that moment the heart continues with electrical activity, it does not stop. In the opinion of cardiologist Pim van Lommel, this patient did not suffer a true cardiac arrest but probably ventricular tachycardia, a condition in which no pulse is detected but the heart still sends some blood flow to the brain, which is in “hypoxia” (not “anoxia” as in a true cardiac arrest) and therefore some residual electrical activity in the brain is to be expected. Here again, the case is not significant.

In general, there are a set of articles like this one, which have explored the residual electrical activity of the brain of rodents (Borjigin, 2013, https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1308285110) or of people (Chawla, 2009, 2017, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19803731). after the moment of clinical death. And attempts have been made to relate this activity to NDEs, as if implying that NDEs are nothing more than the electrical “rattles” of a dying brain.

From our point of view, this argument cannot be seriously sustained for two reasons:

  1. The residual electrical activity measured in the cited articles is very far from the complex, orchestrated and multilocalized activity that would be needed for a level of consciousness as extreme, lucid and ultra-real as that reported during NDEs. The COMA Science Group (University of Liège, Brussels), for example, has already shown the level of electrical sophistication that is developed in the brain to support consciousness (https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.aat7603), a sophistication that certainly does not occur after cardiac arrest. And precisely in the life review, situations are relived with astonishing realism (see the review of Tom Sawyer's life in “Afterwards in Life”, by Bruce Greyson, page 269), and almost always from the perspective of others. There is no residual electrical activity that can explain this level of consciousness.
  2. The numerous NDEs with objective perceptions verified by third parties, occurring far from the patient's physical environment, therefore outside the reach of his senses, are inexplicable by resorting to any type of residual electrical activity. Only in chapter 2 of the book “El Yo No Muere” (see the bibliography on our website) eighteen cases of this type are already collected.

In summary, despite the media impact, we are faced with a very insignificant case, which shows a slight electrical activity during the slow brain shutdown, clearly insufficient to justify the complexity, lucidity and depth of consciousness during an NDE. That consciousness is therefore of another type.

Share

Other news

Life After Life: In Search of the Mysteries Beyond

Argentina’s La Nación newspaper published a comprehensive article—both in its print and digital editions—exploring the phenomenon of near-death experiences (NDEs) and sharing key insights ...
See more →

The next phase of the journey: evidence of the survival of human consciousness after death

The Best in Class (BIC) Awards recognize excellence in healthcare in Spain. Dr. Steve Taylor’s work, presented in six chapters and exploring phenomena that ...
See more →

Part of Healing Is Dying

The testimony of Andrés Arévalo reveals what it feels like to experience hallucinations, a coma, and a near-death experience (NDE). After being intubated for ...
See more →
Scroll to Top