According to scientist Bruce Greyson, consciousness would not depend on our brain

The brain would not be the basis of consciousness, but rather a filter that isolates us from anomalous perceptions. That filter breaks at critical moments and generates near-death experiences, according to the new book by scientist Bruce Greyson.

Although science has already explained that there is nothing paranormal about near-death experiences (NDEs), a new book written by an authoritative scientist hypothesizes that consciousness would not depend on the brain.

This is Bruce Greyson, Doctor of Medicine (MD) and professor of Psychiatry at the University of Virginia, considered the father of NDE research, for whom the relationship between the brain and consciousness has not yet been fully clarified.

FREQUENT AND COINCIDENT

According to oneresearchConducted in 2019, which analyzed more than a thousand participants from 35 countries with experiences of this type, these episodes affect around 10 percent of the population.

The majority of them (87%) speak of an abnormal perception of time, and others report having perceived an exceptional speed of thought (65 percent).

A third group agrees that they experience exceptionally vivid sensations (63 percent) and a fourth group the sensation of feeling separated from their body or outside of it (53 percent).

Another relevant piece of information provided by this study indicates that these experiences are not exclusive to people who experience potentially fatal situations, such as heart attacks or serious accidents. They can also be experienced in other circumstances.

MORE REAL THAN EXPERIENCE

In 2011, aresearchconducted at the University of Cambridge concluded that, contrary to popular belief, near-death experiences are the manifestation of normal brain function that has gone awry during a traumatic event.

Another research conducted in 2017 at the University of Virginia, which consulted 122 people who had experienced NDEs,discoveredthat the memories of those experiences were much more powerful than any lived experience or any product of the imagination.

For the neurosciences, however, any NDE is a subjective phenomenon, a kind of lucid dream, resulting from a "disturbed multisensory bodily integration" that occurs during life-threatening events.

ANOTHER VISION

This explanation, which summarizes well what neuroscience has been able to establish about NDEs, does not, however, rule out other possible interpretations of these episodes, which remain unsatisfactory for some scientists.

This is the case of Bruce Greyson: in a new book (After) he describes a series of documented episodes that, as he explains, do not fit with this consensual interpretation.

He points out that neuroscience considers that consciousness is the result of a brain function, something that is scientifically proven.

He adds, however, that NDEs suggest that consciousness and the brain can dissociate in extreme circumstances, such that the mind (understood as consciousness) can continue to function when the brain appears paralyzed.

SOMETHING IS NOT SQUARE

He explains that not all NDEs are typical of people in a critical situation, but are also produced by psychedelic effects and by disturbances in REM sleep: in both cases they can induce hallucinations similar (not identical) to NDEs.

However, Greyson adds that what brain studies carried out during these experiences parallel to NDEs show is that there is a decrease in brain activity, and not an increase in neuronal dynamics, as might be assumed.

Another piece of information that Greyson provides refers to people with brains devastated by neurological diseases, who momentarily recover their cognitive capacity without, until now, being able to explain this outbreak of lucidity with a non-operational brain.

ALTERNATIVE EXPLANATIONS

This gap is what has led to the formulation of alternative hypotheses to the consensus on the relationship that exists between the brain and consciousness.

Greyson believes that the brain, instead of generating consciousness, would rather be a kind of filter that limits the possibility of perceiving things outside the ordinary senses.

At certain critical moments, this filter could break and show consciousness things that under normal circumstances would remain hidden from our perception.

THE MYSTERY ENDURES

Of course, what Greyson proposes is not conclusive either: he recognizes that the only thing the brain generates is ambiguity and uncertainty and that, surely, we are a long way from discovering the secrets it still hides from us.

Greyson, after 50 years of research, admits that he does not know what causes NDEs, but he rules out that they are caused by a drop in oxygen levels, electrical activity in the brain, or that they are the result of medications administered to patients.

And he concludes: I think the evidence overwhelmingly points to the fact that the physical body is not all we are. There seems to be something that can continue after the body dies. I don't know what to think.

REAL HOPE?

A year ago, philosophy professor at the University of California, John Martin Fischer, published an article in The New York Times in which he analyzes the state of the art regarding NDEs and points out that most represent a journey towards an imaginary realm, but not a successful step towards it.

The same thing happens with the fountain of eternal youth, which we have been talking about since the time of Herodotus (4th century BC), but which we have never reached. In NDEs we go directly to the edge of the universe, but we stop before we cross it, Fischer points out.

And he concludes: NDEs do not show that there is another life, but they are important because they remind us of the possibility of dying well. They point us to something deep and beautiful about death. They give us real hope, not false hope, to face the next part of our journey, whatever it may bring.

Philosophy agrees on this point with what Greyson suggests from science.

Share

Other news

Life After Life: In Search of the Mysteries Beyond

Argentina’s La Nación newspaper published a comprehensive article—both in its print and digital editions—exploring the phenomenon of near-death experiences (NDEs) and sharing key insights ...
See more →

The next phase of the journey: evidence of the survival of human consciousness after death

The Best in Class (BIC) Awards recognize excellence in healthcare in Spain. Dr. Steve Taylor’s work, presented in six chapters and exploring phenomena that ...
See more →

Part of Healing Is Dying

The testimony of Andrés Arévalo reveals what it feels like to experience hallucinations, a coma, and a near-death experience (NDE). After being intubated for ...
See more →
Scroll to Top